Key Laboratory for Micro-Nano Physics and Technology of Hunan Province, Key Laboratory for Micro/Nano Optoelectronic Devices of Ministry of Education, State Key Laboratory of Chemo/Biosensing and Chemometrics, School of Physics and Electronics, Hunan University, Changsha 410082, China
† Corresponding author. E-mail:
anlian.pan@hnu.edu.cn zhuxiaoli@hnu.edu.cn
Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 11374092, 61474040, 61574054, and 61505051), the Aid Program for Science and Technology Innovative Research Team in Higher Educational Institutions of Hunan Province, China, and the Science and Technology Department of Hunan Province, China (Grant No. 2014FJ2001).
1. IntroductionSince the discovery of graphene in 2004, two-dimensional (2D) layered materials have attracted considerable attention in the past decade.[1–5] Atomically thin 2D materials, e.g., MoS
, WS
, ReS
, and SnS
, are burgeoning 2D semiconductor materials for their unique electronic and optical properties.[6–9] Unlike graphene with a zero band gap, these atomically thin 2D materials possess direct band gaps and could give light emission at room temperature, which is important for both electronic and optoelectronic applications. These atomically thin 2D nanosheets derived from the layered materials share many interesting characteristics of the well-known graphene, such as excellent electronic properties, exceptional mechanical flexibility, and partial optical transparency. Furthermore, these 2D nanosheets typically have a well-defined crystalline structure with few surface dangling bonds that traditionally plague most semiconductor nanostructures, and therefore can exhibit excellent electronic properties that are not readily achievable in other semiconductor nanostructures.
Since the application of semiconductor materials is closely related to their band gaps, a vital task in atomically thin 2D semiconductor research is to realize the growth of new 2D materials with tunable band gaps for potential applications in functional electronic/optoelectronic devices.[10–19] Since different atomically thin 2D materials have different band gaps, alloying semiconductors with different band gap variations can be synthesized by controlling the compositional proportions of two or more 2D materials. Thus, the range of band gaps of alloying semiconductors would vary between the minimum and maximum values of the band gaps of all the components. Alloying semiconductors with different band gaps have been widely used in the band gap engineering of bulk semiconductors. For applications in nanoelectronics and nanophotonics, it is very important to achieve semiconductor nanostructures with continuously tuned band gaps.[20–26] Recent advances in 0D and 1D ternary semiconductor structures have shown that their band gaps and light emissions can be tuned gradually by changing their constituent stoichiometries,[27–39] and based on these achieved composition modulated nanostructures, multi-wavelength lasers,[31] wavelength converters,[32] optical diodes,[33] and nanoscale photodetectors[36–38] were realized. For the broad applications in integrated devices and systems, direct growth of these band gap engineered 2D structures should be very important. In this review, we will summarize the recent progress on the band gap engineering of atomically thin two-dimensional semiconductor alloys. Considering from different 2D atomically thin alloys, various research progress will be reviewed systematically.
2.
alloysAs two of the most important transition-metal dichalcogenides (TMDs), atomic layered MoS
and MoSe
have been extensively studied, due to their atomically thin geometry, unique electronic and optical properties, and potential application integrated nanosystems. For monolayer MoS
and MoSe
, the direct band gaps are 1.856 and 1.557 eV, respectively. To precisely control the band gap of these 2D TMDs is of central importance for creating optoelectronic devices with tunable spectral responses. Theoretical studies suggested that mixed Mo(S, Se, Te)
alloys are thermodynamically stable, and thus it is possible to continuously tune their compositions between the constituent limits.[40–43] A cartoon illustrating the atomic structure of a mixed 2D TMDs, along with the constituent parent materials is shown in Fig. 1.[40] In practice, the alloys are modeled by 5×5 supercells. Biplab et al. have studied in detail the electronic structure of atomically thin uniform 2D MoS
Se
and nanosheets to have an understanding of composition dependent tunability of the electronic and optical properties of these nanosheets.[41] Fatih et al. performed DFT calculations to examine the lithium adsorption and diffusion on the hexagonal MoS
Se
monolayers with variation of x for 0.00, 0.33, 0.50, 0.66, and 1.00.[42] In this regard, band gap engineering of 2D alloy MoS
Se
has recently been achieved by using slightly different precursors with different band gaps: (i) mechanically exfoliated MoS
Se
bulk alloy,[44] (ii) creating a composition of mixed alloys by controlling the ratio of the S and Se.[45–62] For example, by using MoS
and MoSe
as precursors, Feng et al. have successfully synthesized MoS
Se
nanosheets (Fig. 1(b)).[45] A typical scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of a representative sample shows that the achieved structures are triangular nanosheets with the edge lengths of 30–80 μm (Fig. 1(c)).[46] With Se dopants, some S2 sites become much brighter and display intensities close to or even higher than the Mo sites (Fig. 1(d)), while the intensities of the Mo sites remain unchanged.[47] Figure 1(e) plots x-ray photo-electron spectra of all the synthesized MoS
Se
monolayers.[45] Figure 1(f) shows the normalized Raman spectra of the asgrown MoS
Se
nanosheets with composition x decreasing gradually from 1 (down-most, pure MoS
) to 0 (upmost, pure MoSe
) excited with a 488 nm argon ion laser, respectively.[46] From the curves a to 1, the intensity of the S−Mo related modes [E
, A
] gradually decreases until they completely disappear, while the Se–Mo related modes [A
, E
] are absent or very weak at the initial stage and gradually come into appearance with the corresponding intensity increased. Lateral composition graded atomic layered 2D MoS
Se
nanosheets have also been successfully synthesized using a simple moving source thermal evaporation method by an improved CVD route.[51]
Figure 2(a) shows the normalized photoluminescence (PL) spectra of the obtained composition modulated MoS
Se
nanosheets excited with a 488 nm argon ion laser.[46] All the samples show single emission bands, with the spectral peaks continuously shifted from 668 nm (for pure MoS
) to 795 nm (for pure MoSe
), which is consistent with the band edge transitions of ternary MoS
Se
thin films. FETs were also fabricated on MoS
Se
monolayers.[45] The MoS
Se
monolayer device exhibited n-type transport behavior with high on/off ratios, and the field-effect mobility
was also calculated. These electrical measurements confirmed semiconductive behavior for all as-grown MoS
Se
monolayers. As a further characterization of the monolayer alloy, the temperature dependence of the PL was also measured. The MoS
Se
monolayer of Fig. 2(d) exhibits typical behavior, with the optical gap
decreasing with temperature.[56] Figure 2(e) gives the wavelength-selected PL emission mapping of an examined composition graded nanosheet alloy in the spectral regions of 680–690, 710–720, 750–760 nm, respectively.[51] Obviously, the short wavelength region (680–690 nm) is mainly located at the center of the nanosheet, while the long wavelength region (750–760 nm) is mostly located around the edge of sheet.
3.
alloysExcept for MoS
Se
, atomically thin 2D WS
Se
alloy has also attracted wide range of interest. The schematic illustration in Fig. 3(a) shows the transformation from WO
(monoclinic crystal) to WS
Se
(hexagonal crystal) through simultaneous sulfurization and selenization.[62] Figure 3(b) illustrates a single-zone furnace utilized in the growth of the monolayer WSe
S
. Because of the much higher chemical activity of S atoms than Se atoms, it is possible to tune the contents in the monolayer WSe
S
by only varying the precursor weight of sulfur powder. The resulting alloy nanosheets are typically monolayers with a well-defined triangular shape, as identified by optical contrast and atomic force microscopy studies (Fig. 3(c)).[64] HRSTEM was utilized to characterize the monolayer WS
Se
, which shows the Z-contrast (Z is the atomic number) as images with atomic-scale resolution, as observed in Fig. 3(d).[62] The hexagonal rings of the alternative W and S/Se atoms in each unit. There are three levels of brightness in Fig. 3(d). The dimmest spots represent the S + S atoms, which are encircled in red; the relatively bright spots are the S + Se atoms, which are encircled in yellow; and the even brighter spots are the Se+Se atoms, which are encircled in blue. Figure 3(e) shows the spatially resolved EDS elemental mapping of the S, Se, and W elements of a typical WS
Se
alloy, all elements show relatively uniform distribution across a triangular domain, indicating composition uniformity throughout the entire domain.[64] To further investigate the structural evolution in the WS
Se
alloy nanosheets, the Raman spectra from the same sample series were collected.[64] The Raman spectra display five main modes for most WS
Se
nanosheets, which can be assigned to A
mode (401.9−419.7 cm
, A
mode (251.6−264.7 cm
), A
mode (379.5−385.2 cm
), E
mode (∼ 354.7–355.9 cm
), and E
−LA
+ A
−LA
mode (135.2−172.5 cm
).
To investigate the band gap modulation in the resulting alloy nanosheets, μ-PL spectra were taken using a micro-Raman microscope and spectrometer excited by a 488 nm argon ion laser (power is 5 μW) in ambient condition. Photoluminescence studies demonstrate that all the monolayer samples display prominent emission with a single sharp peak with full width at half maximum (fwhm) about 25 nm. The PL spectral peak positions are continuously tunable from 626.6 nm (nearly pure WS
) to 751.9 nm (nearly pure WSe
) depending on the exact synthetic conditions (Fig. 4(a)).[64] Furthermore, the spatially resolved mapping of the PL intensity also shows a highly uniform contrast (inset), demonstrating highly uniform optical properties and crystalline quality. To probe the electronic properties of the as-grown monolayer WSe
S
alloy, gated-FET devices based on the monolayer WSe
S
alloy by the EBL was fabricated by Yang et al.[63] The typical current-voltage (
) plots of the FET devices indicates the increase of the drain current by decreasing the back-gate voltage. The band gap tuning capability is ∼ 120 meV by varying the S content in the monolayer WSe
S
alloy. The top-gated FET configuration improves the carrier mobility with two orders larger than that in the back-gated FET device. The evolution of electrical properties and FET threshold voltages can be more clearly seen from an
–
plot under a source-drain bias of 3 V for the nanosheets with increasing sulfur atomic ratio from nearly pure WSe
(brown curve) to nearly pure WS
(black curve, Fig. 4(b)).[64] For the WSe
-rich alloys (∼ 0–0.55 S atomic ratio), the FETs predominantly display p-type semiconductor properties, whereas for the WS
-rich alloys (∼ 0.55 –1 S atomic ratio), the n-type semiconductor properties are mainly observed. The polarization curves (Fig. 4(c)) after internal resistance (iR) compensation obtained at a scan rate of 5 mV
show the normalized current density as a function of the voltage versus RHE in the monolayer WS
Se
(x = 0.43), WS
, WSe
, Pt, and bare GC electrode. Impressively, the monolayer WS
Se
electrode exhibits the significant HER catalytic activity with the lowest onset overpotential of ≈ 80 mV compared to WS
(100 mV) and WSe
(150 mV).
4. WMoS
alloys2D MoS
and WS
can alloy to form atomically thin 2D WMoS
alloy.[65–75] Similar to MoS
and WS
, Mo
W
S
alloy has a layered structure, and each layer consists of two hexagonal S atom layers and a sandwiched Mo/W atom layer. The Mo or W atom sits in the center of a trigonal prismatic cage formed by six S atoms (Fig. 5(a)).[65] The two metal species form homo-nuclear chains along the edges of the triangular W
Mo
S
alloys. Hydrostatic pressure up to 40 GPa was applied to Mo
W
S
layered ternary compound to study the vibrational modes and understand the phonon and lattice distortion for high compressive forces.[71] With increasing pressure, the in-plane E
modes and out-of-plane A
modes follow closely to that of pristine MoS
or WS
. The band gap of Mo
W
S
monolayers could be tuned by MoS
or WS
composition, which was evidenced by PL measurements.[65] As W composition x increases, the A exciton emission (∼ 1.8–2.0 eV) red shifts and then blue shifts (Fig. 5(b)). For Mo
W
S
monolayer alloys, the PL spectra show one strong PL peak, i.e. A-exciton emission (low-energy one), with a weak shoulder B-exciton emission peak at the higher energy side.[67] The PL intensities of the Mo
W
S
monolayer alloys first decrease (due to electron–phonon interaction) and then increase with temperature increasing. Figure 5(c) presents a schematic diagram of the Mo
W
S
photoresistor that was constructed from a PLD-grown film using the wire-masking technique.[68] There are no sampling points at the rise and decay edges from the temporal switching cycle, indicating that the response time of the device is shorter than 150 ms, which is the sampling limit of the measurement system. While alloy scattering was found to be important for alloy compositions 0.5 < x < 0.7, the mobility is found to be limited by LO phonon scattering across the entire range of compositions except for the combination of Morich alloys with very low 2D carrier densities (10
cm
), where the impurity scattering dominates.[69] The morphology, elemental composition, bonding information, and electrocatalytic properties toward hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) of 3D electrodes coated with Mo
W
S
alloys with different Mo/W ratios were also studied.[73]
5.
alloysTriangular Mo
W
Se
monolayers[76–79] with tens of microns in size were successfully grown on SiO
/Si substrates at 780 °C by a low pressure CVD method. According to the simulation, the dimmed Se sites correspond to Se vacancies (VSe) where one Se atom at the site is missing (Fig. 6(a)).[76] Figure 6(b) shows the atomic force micro-scopy (AFM) image of Mo
W
Se
sheets, meaning the height of the monolayer alloy is about 1.3 nm.[78] Figure 6(c) shows an HAADF STEM image of Mo
W
Se
flakes. An atomically resolved image revealed its honeycomb atom arrangement, as shown in the inset of Fig. 6(c).[78] PL measurements on Mo
W
Se
monolayers with different W compositions showed tunable band gap exciton emissions (Fig. 6(d)).[78] As W composition x increases, the PL emission shows a bowing effect, in which emission energy first red shifts to a minimum value at around x = 0.2–0.3 and then monotonically blue shifts. Therefore, the band gap emission of the Mo
W
Se
monolayers can be continuously tuned from 1.56 eV (reached x = 0.21) to 1.65 eV (reached x = 1). Figure 6(e) shows unpolarized Raman spectra of Mo
W
Se
monolayers with different W composition x and the corresponding composition-dependent Raman frequencies.[78] The MoSe
-like E
shifts to lower frequency as the W composition increases. In addition, the second order Raman peaks also shift and showed two-mode behaviors as the W composition changes. Figure 6(f) shows the dynamics of excitons in MoSe
, Mo
W
Se
, and Mo
W
Se
acquired by exciting the monolayers with a ≈ 300 fs pump pulse having a central wavelength of 620 nm and an energy fluence of ≈ 0.9 μJ⋅cm
.[76] The room temperature PL intensity from Mo
W
Se
monolayers is ≈ 10 times stronger than that from MoSe
, accompanied by a longer exciton lifetime, indicating the decrease of defect-mediated nonradiative recombination. The calculated mobility of Mo
W
Se
monolayer FETs with x = 0.39 was about 7.8 × 10
cm
.[78]
6. TMDs alloys with TeUnlike other TMDs, MoTe
and WTe
are distinguished by the existence of a semimetallic distorted octahedral T′ phase with a very small energy barrier from the semiconducting H phase.
The calculations by Rajbanshi et al. showed that MoS
Te
has a direct band gap structure, both the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) are approaching toward the Fermi level with the increase of doping percentage.[41] The formation energy diagram in Fig. 7(a) shows that the T′ phase of pristine monolayer WTe
is thermodynamically more favorable, while monolayer MoTe
is more stable in the H structure due to different contributions from ligand field splitting stabilization and CDW stabilization.[80] It is found that in monolayer W
Mo
Te
alloy, the energy difference between the T′ phase and the H phase is reduced when x approaches the transition point indicating the potential that a smaller amount of charge modulation than that in pristine MoTe
can render the T′ phase more stable than the H phase of monolayer W
Mo
Te
when x is closer to 0.333. At some chosen temperature T, the two phases’ Gibbs or Helmholtz free energies form a free energy landscape that allows determination of which phase or phase mixture minimizes total free energy as a function of W content. Panel (Fig. 7(b)) follows the thermodynamically stable convex hull: the monolayer minimizes its total free energy by existing in the H phase on the left-hand side of point 1, as single phase T′ on the right-hand side of point 3, and as a two-phase coexistence of a W-depleted H phase and a W-rich T′ phase between points 1 and 3. Panel (Fig. 7(c)) applies when long-ranged W diffusion across phases is quenched. Point 2 then marks the transition between metastable single-phase H and metastable single-phase T′.[61] The converted critical voltages required to trigger the phase transition between the H and the T’ phase of monolayer W
Mo
Te
alloy with different compositions are shown in Fig. 7(d).[80] A fast switching device structure is proposed and reasonable critical gate voltages required to induce the phase transition are estimated by a simple capacitor model. The PL spectra of 2H WSe
Te
(x = 0–0.6) monolayer samples excited with a 532 nm laser are collected and shown in Fig. 7(e).[82] All monolayer 2H WSe
Te
show the emission bands, and the spectral peak continuously shifts from 744 nm (pure WSe
) to 857 nm (near infrared). For 1Td sample, as expected, no PL signal is detected when x ≥ 0.6. Figure 7(f) plots the optical gap versus mole fraction of Te for monolayer WSe
Te
.[82] The band gaps are continuously shifted from 1.67 eV (pure WSe
) to 1.44 eV.
7. 2D alloys with GaThe band gap for GaS, GaSe and and GaTe monolayers as 2.5, 2.1, and 1.7 eV (on average), respectively. In Fig. 8(a), wafer-scale GaTe
Se
films are successfully grown by MBE.[83] Ga, Te, and Se elements distribute uniformly over a large range of 0.16 mm×0.16 mm. GaS
Se
multilayers with tunable compositions over the entire range have been successfully synthesized by CVT (Fig. 8(b)).[84] Figure 8(c) displays the UV–visible diffuse reflectance spectrum measured for various compositions of GaS
Se
multilayered nanosheets.[84] The onset of the absorption band, the indirect band gap obtained from the K–M plots, and the PL peak position (at 8 K) all show a linear dependence on the composition, with similar band gap (
) values for any given value of x (Fig. 8(d)).[84] Figure 8(e) shows a schematic view of the fabricated GaSe
Te
nanoflake device.[85] The GaSe
Te
nanoflake photodetectors show extended light response wavelength compared to GaSe (Fig. 8(f)). Also, with increasing Te composition the photocurrent of GaTe
Se
alloys has a rising trend.[83]
9. Other 2D alloysDopping is another effective method to tune the band gap of semiconductor materials. A number of experimental and theoretical studies have been committed to the atomically thin 2D alloys by dopping in recent years.[88–96] Figure 10(a) is the hexagonal bilayer Co
Mo
S
nanosheet synthesized by the CVD method.[88] The A
mode and E
modes show one-mode and two-mode behaviors, respectively. The Co
Mo
S
nanosheet devices demonstrated FET characteristics of a n-type semiconductor (Fig. 10(b)), with a mobility as high as 0.52 cm
/(V⋅s), the on/off ratio (about 10) is lower than the reported bilayer MoS
flakes.[88] Meanwhile, good quality Sn
Mn
Se
films with relatively high Mn concentrations have been successfully grown by MBE on GaAs (111)B substrates.[89] The XRD patterns for the Sn
Mn
Se
films are shown in Fig. 10(c). The samples show only (00l) peaks of the SnSe
structure, illustrating excellent c-axis-oriented epitaxial growth. Figure 10(d) shows the Mn concentration as a function of Mn effusion cell temperature
. One can see that the Mn concentration increases linearly from about 42% to 66% as
increases from 670 °C to 760 °C. The electronic and magnetic properties of Mn-doped monolayer WS
were also investigated by Zhao et al.[90] According to their simulation calculations, a significant portion of the alloy’s spin density is localized on the Mn atom. For each considered Mn-doped WS
configuration, the formation energy is lower under S-rich conditions, which indicates that it is energy favorable and relatively easier to incorporate Mn atom into WS
nanosheet under S-rich experimental conditions. In addition, Deniz et al. investigated the electronic and magnetic properties of a ReS
monolayer substitutionally doped with transition metal and nonmetal atoms.[91] The mixed-metal fere crystal compounds, [(SnSe)
]
[(Nb
Mo
)Se
]
with x = 0, 0.26, 0.49, 0.83, and 1, were successfully produced via adaptation of the modulated elemental reactant method.[93] Template-based sputtering method is used first to fabricate Au nanoantenna (NA)/MoS2 heterostructures with an enhanced exciton energy.[95] The PL spectrum red-shifting and intensity attenuation happen in the n-type doping of GQD/MoS
heterostructure configuration based on optical doping mechanism.[96]
In conclusion, great progress has been made in recent years in search for the band gap engineering of atomically thin 2D semiconductor alloys. Up to now, almost all kinds of 2D semiconductor alloys have been obtained, and recent studies have shown exciting potential of these atomically thin semiconductor alloys, including the demonstration of atomically thin transistors, a new design of vertical transistors, as well as new types of optoelectronic devices such as tunable photovoltaic devices and light emitting devices. In addition to the growth and corresponding device applications, it is equally important to pursue the novel physical properties of the band gap engineered 2D nanosheets and use them in new 2D semiconductor-based functional device designs.
Although the progress achieved in band gap engineering of atomically thin 2D semiconductor nanosheets represents only an initial success in this new field of material science research. Many new opportunities and challenges remain in the coming years, such as the instability of 2D semiconductor alloys in the air, which is still the key problem when things come to related material applications. Is there any way to make the raw materials more harmless in order to fit with the requirements of the environment? We are looking for the answers.
Above all, through the tireless efforts of researchers and the development of research technology, alloys from other 2D materials, such as 2D metal halide, and 2D black phosphorus which attracts great attention lately will gradually enter the people’s vision in the near future.